An Ottoman Era Aubergine dish inspired by Agatha Christie’s novel, Crooked House

For the final episode of the third season of the Whodunnit Dinners podcast, Helen picked one of Agatha Christie’s own favourites, ‘Crooked House’ (1949) to share with Katie and was fully delighted by her decision. It is not one of her best-known novels but is an absolute joy to read. 

What makes Crooked House such a great novel? 

Christie considered this novel one of her personal favorites and among the books that satisfied her the most. She is quoted as saying "Writing Crooked House was pure pleasure and I feel justified in my belief that it is one of my best." 

As a psychological study rather than a village murder full of cozy English tropes, it differs from many of her other books. It tells the story of a multi-generational, post-war family living under one roof, and explores dark themes of inherited dysfunction and moral immaturity. There is an unhealthy, interdependent generational dynamic reminiscent of the nursery rhyme "There Was a Crooked Man":

The book follows amateur investigator Charles Hayward as he pursues a shocking family murder within the Leonides household. It begins with Charles returning to London after World War II, only to learn that his fiancée, Sophia Leonides, will not marry him yet because her wealthy grandfather, Aristide Leonides, has just been murdered and she wants the matter resolved and the killer caught before she brings someone else into her family. Aristide is murdered when his regular eye medicine (eserine) is replaced with a fatal dose of poison. Two more murders of members of the household follow. 

The setting for the rest of the book is a grand but ramshackle mansion outside London known as Three Gables. “The Gables was a little crooked house that had grown like a mushroom in the night - that dream-like fairy tale quality of the property.” Like the creepy house, the family members are discomforting and described as ‘ruthless’ ‘cold-blooded’ and ‘arrogant’. 

Christie works hard to convey the historical context in Crooked House. As a person who had experienced both the First and Second World War herself, she writes about life in the aftermath of a brutal World war with a truly authentic voice. 

Agatha also adds some tantalising musings on the nature of evil and killing within the novel: “I’ve never met a murderer who wasn’t vain . . . It’s their vanity that leads to their undoing, nine times out of ten. They may be frightened of being caught, but they can’t help strutting and boasting and usually they’re sure they’ve been far too clever to be caught.”

Helen enjoyed the book so much that she recommended it to two members of her family. After reading it, her son pointed out that it bore a striking similarity to the first Knives Out film and he was totally right: the premise, the setting, the dysfunctional family, the poisoning, the method of death, and the twist on the will - it really feels likely that Crooked House was an inspiration for the movie. 

What makes the podcast recipe so interesting? 

As the murdered family patriarch was Greek, from a part of the world called Smyrna, Helen had challenged Katie on the previous podcast to research Greek food to complement the book. In fact, Smyrna is an ancient Greek port city on the Aegean coast of Anatolia in Turkey, whose official name has been İzmir  since 1930. So the specific challenge was a Greek recipe that might also have been cooked up on the Turkish coast. 

The recipe Katie uncovered was the wonderfully-named  Imam Bayildi, which means 'the Imam fainted'. Katie shares the three possible reasons why this dish is named after an overwhelmed priest on the podcast.

Despite the elaborate name, it is a simple dish of vegetarian ingredients. For four people you would need an aubergine (egg plant) per person, stuffed with onions, tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, parsley and a little salt, pepper, sugar and water. To find out how to make it, the website world.food will give you all the details you need. Tasty stuff. 

Sidenote - during the course of the discussion about Greek/Turkish food and doner kebabs, Helen brought up the iconic Bristol institution called Jason Donervan. For more details and to plan your visit, click on this link! 

How long does Imam Bayildi take to make?

The actual prep takes about 45 minutes and then you will need to allow over an hour for cooking time. The filling is very straightforward but you should read the instructions for the aubergine carefully if you have not prepared one before. Traditionally, it is a dish eaten cold or at room temperature, so let it cool down to eat in the traditional way. 

Bring the mystery to your table

Pair this Greek dish with a murder mystery of your own: it could go nicely with Ye Gods! Or for another spooky manor murder, purchase Murder at Down-at-Heel Abbey or browse our full collection here for more.

Listen to the podcast 

If you’ve found this Greek/Turkish recipe suitably tempting, you should take a listen to the full Whodunnit Dinners podcast, which will take you through the plot, background and themes of Agatha Christie’s ‘Crooked House’ and add flesh on the bones of the story behind the odd name of the dish. To hear the full Whodunnit Dinners podcast, click on one of the links below. 

Apple podcasts page for Whodunnit Dinners 

Whodunnit Dinners podcast on Spotify

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published